This category can only be viewed by members.

Musings From Manchester: Compare and contrast

The current political language of stark opposites is nothing new to the practitioner. Geoffrey Shindler explains ‘The most important conflict and contrast of the day is between tax planning and tax avoidance. To my mind both are legitimate with or without vituperative epithets like “aggressive”. But HMRC appear to take a different view of the …
This post is only available to members.

Survivorship: The importance of the matrimonial home

Simon Goulding examines the interaction of the principle of survivorship with claims under s9 of the Inheritance (Provision for Family and Dependants) Act 1975 ‘Where a will or the rules on intestacy have failed to provide a reasonable level of financial provision for a dependant, a potentially powerful statutory provision which may reverse the effects …
This post is only available to members.

Chattels: Cutting the Gordian knot

Hannah Southon explores a judgment concerning a rarely used power of the court to direct the division of jointly-owned chattels ‘The case serves to underline the fact that if it is important to a donor who desires to dispose of assets by gifting them outright, rather than settling them on trust.’What relief is available from …
This post is only available to members.

Trusts: When is a ‘trust’ not a trust?

Katherine Hallett highlights a case that demonstrates the weight the court gives to the fact matrix when considering a possible declaration of trust ‘Practitioners should not refer to a “trust” unless they do actually intend to import the full legal meaning of that word into their document.’ Mr and Mrs Singha divorced in 2010. A …
This post is only available to members.

Wills: Pub talk

James Lister and Fenner Moeran QC analyse a case that demonstrates how a Beddoe order is applied in practice ‘The trustees were faced with a significant difficulty: how to realise the interests of the beneficiaries to divide the property equally between them when one of them was in occupation of the property to the exclusion …
This post is only available to members.

Tax And Asset Protection: The bank of mum and dad

Guy Rendell and Graeme Fraser give the lowdown on parents helping children to buy property ‘There is a broad array of options for parents to assist their children. Selecting the right option will often be a case of balancing the somewhat competing interests of tax efficiency and asset protection.’With stagnant wages and high property prices, …
This post is only available to members.

Jersey: Independent process

Julie Melia outlines the procedure for will-making and probate in Jersey, and the consequences where it is not followed ‘While a will drawn anywhere is the world may, provided that it complies with the requirements of the jurisdiction of the deceased’s domicile, be accepted for Jersey probate purposes, a will dealing with immovable property must …
This post is only available to members.

IHT And Charities: A matter of interpretation

Simrun Garcha discusses the lessons from Routier on inheritance tax charity relief and jurisdiction ‘The words “held on trust for charitable purposes” contained a requirement that a qualifying charitable trust must be governed by the law of some part of the UK and subject to the jurisdiction of the UK courts.’The Court of Appeal’s recent …
This post is only available to members.

Trust Deeds: The deed in the drawer

Lisa Feng examines the implications of Swift v Ahmed [2015] ‘The issue for the court was whether a real and substantial purpose of the deed was to place assets beyond the reach of (or otherwise prejudice the interests of) the trustee’s creditors.’The case of Swift Advances Plc v Ahmed [2016] is an example of what …
This post is only available to members.

Trustees: Clear blue water

Gillian Christian highlights a landmark Isle of Man judgment that casts doubt on Pitt v Holt [2013] ‘The principle behind Hastings-Bass refers to the jurisdiction of the court to intervene and set aside a transaction entered into by a trustee (and all fiduciaries) on the grounds of “inadequate deliberation” in the exercise of a discretion.’In …
This post is only available to members.