This category can only be viewed by members.

Costs: Trials and tribulations

Paul Jones considers the costs implications of a dispute that was settled on the day of the trial, before the trial had taken place ‘The key in this case was that the third case of Section B of Table 6B clearly and expressly only applied where the case settles prior to the date of trial …
This post is only available to members.

Material Contribution: Causes for concern

Julian Matthews highlights a case that demonstrates the courts’ approach to contribution to injury ‘Even where there were multiple causes, if the defendant’s breach of duty had materially contributed to one of those causes and that contribution was material to the development of the condition overall, then the principles of material contribution applied, and causation …
This post is only available to members.

Book Review: All together?

Jonathan Dingle assesses Employer’s Liability Claims (2016 edition) In a former professional life, when serving in the Royal Navy, the author quickly learned that Royal Marines were among the finest individuals into whose hands you could trust your life. A privilege to command and lead, they were the right people to have at your side …
This post is only available to members.

Case Report: Gentry v Lee Miller [2016] EWCA Civ 141

Insurers; vehicle loss; allegations of fraud; acknowledgement of service ‘Perhaps the broader application of Gentry is to provide yet another illustration how the courts are unwilling to tolerate delay and default even if, as here, the party applying for relief was an insurer that had only subsequently been added to the action and seemed to …
This post is only available to members.

Cost Management: Profiting from agents, delegation and budgeting

Richard Allen summarises common grass roots costs issues and the importance of monitoring litigation resources ‘The matter of Nicholas Crane v Canons Leisure Centre proceeded to the Court of Appeal, who by a majority held that the costs consultant’s fees were “base costs” within the meaning of the CCFA and that the success fee was …
This post is only available to members.

Infant Settlements: What the court wants…

Christopher Taylor outlines the approaches to getting court approval for infant damages ‘The courts undertake thousands of infant approval hearings up and down the country each year, most conducted before the District Bench, and yet there is little guidance on how these cases are to be conducted.’ The rules surrounding children and protected parties is …
This post is only available to members.

CFAs: Held in the balance

Reuben Glynn examines the precedents for contesting the assignment of a CFA ‘Jenkins was not appealed, and remains good law. The problem is it was only a High Court decision so, in principle, could be departed from by another High Court judge or overturned by the Court of Appeal.’ We have a new battle ground …
This post is only available to members.

Financial Awards: Tread carefully

Alison Taylor explains methods for avoiding professional negligence claims and maximising quantum ‘From a negligence perspective, not considering the impacts of eligibility for statutory funding both pre- and post-settlement can be a significant issue given the potential support available and sums involved.’A growth area of my work as a financial adviser is acting as an …
This post is only available to members.

Breach Of Duty: Employer’s liability claims post Jackson

Andrew Mckie examines the Enterprise and Regulatory Reform Act (ERRA) 2013 and the impact of the Small Claims Track (2017) ‘Claimant lawyers will now have to be more careful than ever to show there has been a breach of duty of the common law duty of care and that breach caused the accident.’ It may …
This post is only available to members.

Legal Principle: Overturning the Cookson defect

Christopher Sharp QC explains why Knauer v Ministry of Justice marks a fundamental change in claims for future loss of dependency in fatal accident cases ‘The decision in Knauer was not unexpected but it is to be welcomed. It is to be hoped that a similar opportunity to have the Supreme Court review the position …
This post is only available to members.